UNJUSTIFIED
Lord Carlile, the independent reviewer
of anti-terrorism laws, said police are making
unjustified searches of members of the public to
provide "racial balance" to stop and
search statistics.
He said he knew of cases where suspects were
stopped by officers even though there was no
evidence against them.
He warned that police were wasting money by
carrying out "self-evidently unmerited
searches" which were an invasion of civil
liberties and "almost certainly
unlawful".
Lord Carlile, a Lib Dem peer and QC, condemned
the wrongful use of Section 44 of the Terrorism
Act 2000 in his annual report on anti-terror
laws.
He said police were carrying out the searches on
people they had no basis for suspecting so they
could avoid accusations of prejudice.
As the terror threat against Britain is largely
from Islamist extremists, the figures show
disproportionately more Muslims and therefore
more Asians being searched than whites. (Source: Daily Telegraph, Jun/09) |
|
|
STOP AND SEARCH
People from the ethnic minorities are far
more likely to be stopped and searched than whites,
according to the latest police figures for Derbyshire. A
report to Derbyshire Police Authority gives figures for
the number of people who have been stopped, according to
their ethnicity, during the 2002/03 financial year.
It reveals that during this period 7,569 of the country's
917,653 white population have been stopped, amounting to
8.2 searches per 1,000 population. During the same period
944 people from ethnic minorities were stopped and
searched, out of a population of 38,640. This means there
were 24.43 searches per 1,000 population. Ethnic
minorities are people who are black, Asian, unknown and
other, based on new census classifications.
The figures are up slightly on last year, where there
were 7.48 white people searched per thousand and 21.35
per thousand ethnic minorities searched. Chief Constable
David Coleman told a police authority meeting that
individual officers were monitored to ensure they were
stopping people for the right reasons and without being
discriminatory.
He added, "The vast majority of stop-search activity
is conducted in inner city areas where there is more
poverty and the majority of the population is made up of
ethnic minorities. That's not saying in any way that
ethnic minorities are disproportionately responsible for
crime but it is the case that a lot of crime takes place
in those areas."
Police say 79% of the force's searched on ethnic
minorities took place in it's D division, which covers
Derby and South Derbyshire. This is compared to 78% of
the country's ethnic minority population living in this
area. From the searches during this financial year, of
the 7,569 white people searched, 1,093 were arrested,
equating to 14.4% rate. The rate for ethnic minority was
177 out of 944 were arrested, which is 18.8%.
Gulnaz Nawaz who is of Asian origin and lives in
Normanton Road, said, "I think the police should be
fairer and more equal when they're choosing who to stop.
Why should they stop Asian and black people just because
they're living in the city?" Lloyd Newby of Stenson
Avenue, Derby, who is deputy leader of the city's West
Indian Association, said, "It's a known problem and
I'm not 100% sure why Afro-Carribeans are being stopped.
I'd urge people who feel they're being harassed to ask
the reason they're being stopped and take the officer's
badge number."
Muslim leaders accused police of racism
after figures showed searches of Asians have more than
trebled since 9/11. There were 744 Asians stopped and
searched in 2001 under the new Terrorism Act. But in the
2002 the number shot up to 2,989. Eight out of ten
searches were by the Met and City of London police. The
number of whites and blacks stopped rose less
dramatically, yet the Home Office report, Statistics on
Race and the Criminal Justice System, revealed just 13%
of searches resulted in an arrest. The figures have led
worried ministers to announce a new team to advise police
on use of stop-and-search powers.
Massoud Shadjareh, spokesman for the Islamic Human Rights
Commission, said, "We are quite appalled. This
proves there is a lot of Islamophobia when dealing with
terrorism.The very people security forces should rely on
helping them fight terror are being alienated ."
Abdal Ullah, a Muslim member of the Metropolitan Police
Authority, said, "Muslims are a scapegoat. The young
will be alienated." And Iqbal Sacranie, secretary
general of the Muslim Council, said fear about Islamic
terrorism were no excuse. He added, "Terrorism is a
concern to all of us. But it doesn't mean that whenever
you see young people or people that may be Muslims they
can be simply stopped and questioned."
But Glen Smyth, chair of the Met Police Federation
representing rank and file London officers, said the
figures were a natural result of the security situation.
Announcing the new unit, Home Office minister Hazel
Blears insisted, "I am very concerned about the
undermining of confidence in the criminal justice system
by stop and search. It has to be intelligence-led and
can't just be to harass people." But the report also
showed most of the 869,164 stop and searches in 2002 were
crime, not terror, related. The most common reason to
stop blacks and Asians was to search for drugs. (Source:
Daily Mirror)
Their school was closed for the day because
of the weather so Jacob Mogre, 12, and his friend Charlie
Stakim, 11, took their sledge to a snow-covered hill.
Just as they were about to begin a long slide down the
slope, they were beckoned by two police community support
officers. The boys were asked why they were not in school
and then quizzed about damage to a nearby fence. They
told the officers they knew nothing about the fence, but
instead of simply being allowed to carry on playing they
were given an official stop and search form
which they had to sign themselves. Sledging
downhill was given as the grounds for intervention.
Their parents have now been told the youngsters
details will now go on a police database. A Sussex Police
spokesman said the PCSOs were investigating a call from
the public about youths causing criminal damage over the
weekend and the word sledging was used purely
as a shorthand means of recording the event. (Source: Daily Mail, Jan/10)
Racist police officers are the reason some
forces target too many black people when they stop and
search crime suspects, according to a leaked report from
the state equality watchdog. It said that some forces use
their powers to search people on the streets too often
and that the use of the powers against ethnic minorities
is 'excessive'. A draft of the report by the Equality and
Human Rights Commission leaked to the Guardian newspaper
said that prejudice among police officers was a reason
why black people are singled out more often to the be
stopped and searched. (Source: Daily Mail)
The murder of a teenage boy stabbed to death in the
street is 'about as bad as it gets', a senior detective
said. Detective Chief Inspector Mark Dunne said Yemurai
Lovemore Kanyangarara's murder was among the worst he had
investigated in 25 years. He was dead in less than five
minutes, the eighth teenager to be murdered in London
this year, six of whom have been fatally stabbed. The attackers, who like the victim were black, fled the scene very quickly. But
rarely has a doctor, lawyer, dentist, nurse etc of any
ethnic background been stopped and searched. If people
don't like being searched then they should f***ing
behave!. (Source: Daily Mail)
|
|
|