FUEL TAX

Fuel prices have hit a record high as it emerged the government is collecting a tax windfall of £240million a month from the surging cost of oil. The bonus means the Treasury could cut fuel duty by 6p a litre without affecting its economic forecasts. The Chancellor takes 67p from every pound spent on diesel and petrol, bringing in around £32billion a year in duty and VAT. However, the Treasury is netting an extra £240million a month in taxes on North Sea profits because the price of crude oil is higher than expected.

The figures on Treasury revenues were compiled by accountants Grant Thornton, which looked at the North Sea oil tax and corporation tax paid by firms such as BP and Shell. It said officials could act to minimise the impact of higher oil prices on consumers and the economy. Maurice Fitzpatrick, Grant Thornton tax expert, said, "So far, the high oil price, and the resulting high price at the pump, has not led to the intense pressure on the Treasury which occurred in September 2000. At that time, the high oil price sparked a blockade at oil refineries and panic at the pumps." (Source: Daily Mail, Oct/07)

The price of fuel in the UK is a complicated business and it changes month to month as the cost of crude oil rises and falls with international demand. British drivers also pay two taxes on the petrol they buy at the pump - Fuel Duty and VAT. Of these, fuel duty remains by far the most significant, and remains the most controversial. If a litre of unleaded petrol costs 85p, 21.7p will be the production costs and profit, around 51p will be duty and 12.5p will be VAT on top of all that.

The major change in petrol taxation came under the Conservatives in 1993 with the introduction of the Fuel Price Escalator. The escalator was designed as a means both to raise money and discourage car use on environmental grounds. At the time, British fuel was the third-cheapest in Europe. It is now the most expensive. The annual fuel escalator was set in 1993 at 3% above the rate of inflation. On its introduction it added three pence to a litre of fuel and raised the tax burden on unleaded petrol to 72.8% of the total cost.

When the Conservatives left office in 1997, the escalator was at 5% and had contributed a 11.1 pence rise to the cost of unleaded fuel. Tax as a proportion of total cost stood at 76.3%. On taking office, Labour's chancellor Gordon Brown increased the fuel escalator further and put three pence onto a litre of petrol in his first Budget. That pushed taxes up to 81.5% of the total price of fuel. While duty rose by two pence a litre as part of the 2000 Budget, Gordon Brown also scrapped the fuel price escalator, saying that future increases would be decided on the basis of the "due Budget process".

At the time, and perhaps rather ironically given current events, the AA said that it was the first budget in seven years in which "drivers can take some heart". According to the Tories this isn't good enough. They say that since Labour came to office, the petrol pump price of unleaded petrol has risen by around 71%. And while there have been large jumps in the price of oil, the party blames what it says is Labour's 16p per litre rise in taxes. Figures from the Institute of Fiscal Studies tell a slightly different story. The Conservative figure of 16p per litre is a combination of duty and VAT.

While the actual amount brought in by VAT rises with increases in fuel prices and duty, it is calculated at the same 17.5% level which the present government inherited from the Conservatives. Fuel campaigners argue that VAT should only be calculated on the cost of the fuel rather than on the fuel and the duty together. If VAT was not charged on the duty, the motorist would save around 8p per litre at September 2000 prices. None of the parties appear to support that move. Leaving aside VAT, fuel duty increases under Labour amount to 12 pence per litre - just slightly more than the rise caused by the escalator under the Conservatives.

Because of the rise in world oil prices, the proportion of the total fuel cost that is tax has fallen from 85% (March 1998) to 72.3% today - still one of the highest levels in the world - something that ministers have sought to stress in interviews. With the Tories pledging a three pence a litre cut should they come to power, the question is whether the Government should cut fuel duty and whether the country can afford it.

Gordon Brown is raking in so much extra tax from rising oil prices that he could afford to cut 11p off a litre of petrol. If oil went up to $50 dollars a barrel, the Chancellor could even drop the basic rate of income tax by 2p without denting his coffers. Maurice Fitzpatrick, economics chief at business advice group Numerica, said, "If the oil price reached a sustained $50 a barrel then the price of petrol would be above 90p a litre from 80p now. The Treasury would be receiving a windfall of an additional £5.5billion per annum. This would be sufficient to cut fuel duties by 11p per litre, or income tax by 2p."

Next >>>--